1. What the $1.8bn actually is
| Element | What it is | Status |
|---|---|---|
| TAM ≈ $1.8bn | ~15 M food-service outlets × ~$100/month × 10 analytics plug-ins | top-down scenario, not a forecast; 1% penetration assumed |
| SAM | Türkiye + EU tourist cities, ~1.2 M outlets | still theoretical; no signed customer |
| SOM | One city, one district, 90 days, five KPIs | the only number with evidence behind it |
Bottom-up cross-check that survives a diligence call: global waste-management services ≈ $1.3–1.6 tn/yr (market-research range, not audited). Analytics is a thin software layer on top — realistically 0.1–0.3% of that, i.e. $1.3–4.8 bn of addressable software revenue. A single vendor at 0.1% of that is $1–5 M/yr. State that number, not "$1.8bn".
2. The margin claim, corrected
gross margin — normal for pure software
net margin — normal for a growing SaaS
revenue needed for a $100 M profit at those net margins
This is not pure software: it needs field validation, municipal sales cycles of 9–18 months and local partners. So "$1.8bn × 20% net" is an exit-state scenario, not a year-3 line. The deck now labels it: "illustrative top-down scenario, zero signed customers."
3. Evidence that survives scrutiny
| Claim | Source status | Safe phrasing |
|---|---|---|
| Collection + transport = 60–70% of system cost | World Bank What a Waste 2.0; Boskovic et al. 2016 (up to 70%) | "reported at 60–70% across World Bank and peer-reviewed studies" |
| Hotel food waste −26% in year 1, ~7:1 ROI | Champions 12.3, industry coalition, self-reported | "an industry coalition reports 26% year-1 reduction; not independently audited" |
| Food loss & waste ≈ $1 tn/yr | UNEP Food Waste Index | "UNEP estimate of economic value — not a budget" |
| Uber reached ~70 countries, 15 000+ cities | public trackers | "precedent for asset-light scaling — not a partnership" |
4. What the deck must add, and what it must remove
Add
- One named pilot city, one district, 90 days, five KPIs — before any market slide.
- A "what would make us wrong" slide: if public review text does not predict waste generation, the model fails — and here is the test.
- An appendix pointing to the municipal one-pager, with the note: "this is what we show a city; the market sizing is for investors only."
Remove or relocate
- $1.8bn, 20% margin, "150 000 customers" — out of anything a city officer will see.
- "MRV Core", "NLP engine", "ecosystem" → plain: "we read public reviews and rank streets".
- Any implication of UN, UNEP, ISWA, XPRIZE or Uber partnership. Precedent is not partnership.
5. Documents
- Municipal file (TR) — no market sizing, no margin, no "SaaS".
- INVESTOR_NOTE_MARKET_SIZING.md — this page as a document.
- Investor / pavilion deck (PPTX) — the deck that must not be handed to a city.
- Detailed proposal · XPRIZE precedent package